Chart Metrics vs. Cultural Mettle: Deconstructing the Narrative of Hip-Hop’s “Fall”

The removal of Kendrick Lamar and SZA‘s “luther” from the Billboard Hot 100 chart has reignited the heated debate of rap’s decline in 2025. The conversations are unsurprising when this is the first time in over 35 years that there’s not a single rap song in the Top 40. Its eviction (and I use that word deliberately) from the Hot 100 is a direct result of Billboard’s newest Top 40 rule changes, which states that songs need to reach a certain chart position after a number of weeks, or it’ll get booted.

The exit of “luther” reignites the contentious debate of rap’s commercial decline in 2025. While this theory is supported by specific, quantifiable metrics that are viewed separately, are these commercial stress points accurate indicators of creative exhaustion or cultural failure?

To clarify, there’s a need to maintain the strong distinction between cultural influence and commercial performance. The latter regularly hinges on metrics like chart positions, units sold and domestic market shares — all of which can be affected by a change in chart methodology. However, cultural influence is an entity on its own. The genre’s ability to not just influence, but also shape global trends like fashion, language and even other genres precedes the quantifiable metrics of commercial performance.

The Big Commercial Question

Although R&B/Hip-hop is still the dominant genre in the US, Luminate’s data reveals that the genre’s market share dropped from nearly 30% in 2020 to 25.3% in 2024. Add that to Billboard’s latest Hot 100 Top 40 rule change, and hip-hop’s presence on the chart is severely suppressed. The lack of visibility gives the impression that rap is on a steady decline, even if its underlying total consumption volume remains massive.

Hip-hip faces strong competition with the increase in popularity of other genres. Country music has attracted a much younger audience thanks to its links with TikTok. Cross-genre albums like Beyoncé‘s Cowboy Carter and Post Malone‘s F-1 Trillion have validated the appeal; 34 spots on the Billboard Top 200 were occupied by country albums in 2024, marking a 30% increase from the year prior. Meanwhile, the global market is experiencing a surge in formerly-regional genres like afrobeats and reggaeton, with those records also hitting streaming and Billboard charts. Hip-hop’s market share is falling because listeners’ digital tastes are shifting, making space for other genres.

Chart Impact = Cultural Longevity?

Despite optics suggesting the “fall of hip-hop,” its enduring cultural vitality proves that it’s more than just commercial viability. Hip-hop is more than a music genre. Its influence on ’90s and early ’00s style, combined with tech-integrated clothing, generates almost $2 billion USD annually. Hip-hop also serves as the lingua franca of the modern, chart-topping music we hear today. These albums have universally adopted a number of rap’s idiosyncrasies, including production elements, flows and even the beloved 808 drum machine. Hip-hop’s rhythmic structure has, in a very strong sense, formed the blueprint of contemporary popular music, regardless of how the track is ultimately classified.

There’s also a need to mention hip-hop’s various sub-genres which, in the modern age, have started off as community-supported efforts. Drill music, irrespective of whether it’s in the UK or in Brooklyn, have been fan-favorites for a long while. Plugg or Pluggnb also found its initial audience on SoundCloud. Although they don’t hit the Top 40, the creative energy is evidently bursting at the seams. These sub-genres thrive in digital communities as artists no longer need old media to broaden their reach. This disconnect between what traditional media is aware of versus what’s actually popular online is why many legacy critics keep pushing the narrative that hip-hop is in decline.

Outside the United States, hip-hop is still the most-consumed music genre worldwide. The UK’s top genre in 2021 was rap, and countries like France, Russia and Germany are developing their own local scenes. This supports the statement that hip-hop still has a profound local relevance. Despite its performance in the domestic market, hip-hop’s deep cultural influence ensures its longevity.

The Algorithm vs. Artistry

Let’s get this out of the way: hip-hop doesn’t lack quality. It’s the genre’s long-form, lyrical narrative that directly contrasts with catchy, repetitive loops that the digital world favors. Lyrical hip-hop’s narrative density wasn’t made to survive the algorithm, forcing many to adapt and shorten their output for the sake of virality. If a song doesn’t drop its catchiest segment within the first 30 seconds, the chances of the track achieving viral fame is greatly dashed. It forces artist to sacrifice lyrics and narrative depth in exchange for commercial success. Even Billboard recognized this loophole, plugging it by introducing minimum runtime rules and effectively putting an end to short, exploitative songs that harm hip-hop artistry.

But hip-hop’s biggest commercial challenge is, unfortunately, due its own success. The normalized used of hip-hop’s specialties and its integration into popular gave birth to albums that are universally enjoyed. Hip-hop’s contribution to the entire recorded music ecosystem is often overlooked when other genres use its rhythmic structure. Modern pop and country are frequently infused with numerous R&B and hip-hop elements, but since they’re traditionally classified as either pop or country, the true depth of hip-hop’s involvement is masked.

When you look at commercial data and cultural indicators separately, it builds the perception that hip-hop is falling off. When they’re looked at together, however, it’s a completely different story. Hip-hop isn’t dying. There isn’t a creative drought. It’s simply facing the modern age’s digital infrastructures and competitive dynamics. Overly relying on something as volatile as Top 40 chart metrics, which can be easily skewed by decisions like rule changes, and overlooking hip-hop’s contributions unjustly paints a false picture. If anything, the non-stop obsession with whether hip-hop is declining is probably the best evidence that it’s completely alive. No other genre gets so heavily dissected just because the market share moves a couple of points.

“Hip-hop isn’t dying. There isn’t a creative drought. It’s simply facing the modern age’s digital infrastructures and competitive dynamics.”

Within two weeks, rap is already back in the Top 40 thanks to Megan Thee Stallion’s “Lover Girl.” There’s almost no doubt that rap’s resiliency is undeniable. When the public suggests that hip-hop has fallen off, it’s really just taking a breather, momentarily pausing so it can continue to evolve. Hip-hop was, and always will be, one of the most influential cultural forces in modern music.

Click here to view full gallery at Hypebeast